Good For Whom? An analysis of desegregation efforts in Oklahoma's historically Black townships
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
In 1954, the Supreme Court’s ruling in Brown v. Board of Education declared de jure racial segregation in public schools unconstitutional, which many had hoped would lead to greater opportunities for Black students. While scholars have examined school desegregation at length through the perspectives of Black youth, most existing research focuses on urban and suburban contexts, leaving research on school desegregation in rural areas underdeveloped. This dissertation investigates the retrospective perspectives of ten Black adults, ages 66 to 76, who were educated in rural public schools in Oklahoma’s historically Black townships during the implementation of desegregation initiatives from 1954 to 1974. By using narrative inquiry, data were collected through semi-structured interviews with ten participants and analyzed thematically. The participants described how they encountered school desegregation at different ages, grade levels, and community contexts. From the analyses, the following central themes were derived: loss of cultural identity and community institutions, legacy of strong Black educational communities, emotional and social challenges of desegregation, and recognition of expanded opportunities. Together, these themes suggested that school desegregation disrupted Black educational ecosystems in certain ways. However, Black adults also described what they used to succeed in desegregated schools. By examining experiences with school desegregation in rural Black townships, this study contributes to scholarship on school desegregation by documenting an under-explored context. This study further offers suggestive evidence that school desegregation policies may have carried unintended consequences that reshaped educational, cultural, and communal life in rural Black townships in lasting ways.